By Kevin Hardy, Stateline.org
As each state surrounding Idaho legalized marijuana, state Rep. Bruce Skaug began to view it as inevitable that the Gem State would observe swimsuit.
Not anymore.
Skaug, a Republican, supported two payments this legislative session taking intention at marijuana use: one to impose a compulsory minimal $300 high-quality for possession and one other that will take away the best of voters to legalize pot on the poll field.
He believes different states are beginning to remorse liberalizing marijuana use, due to potential well being considerations and lackluster revenues from marijuana gross sales.
“Trying round at different states which have legalized marijuana, it’s not improved their states as a spot to lift a household, to do enterprise,” he mentioned. “It simply hasn’t come by means of with the guarantees that we heard years in the past for these states.”
Idaho’s not alone. After years of increasing authorized entry, lawmakers in a number of states this yr have focused marijuana in numerous methods.
To assist shut price range gaps, officers in Maryland, Michigan and New Jersey have proposed elevating marijuana taxes. Well being considerations have pushed lawmakers in states together with Colorado and Montana to aim to cap the extent of tetrahydrocannabinol, or THC, the first psychoactive part in hashish, in marijuana merchandise offered at dispensaries. And a few lawmakers have even tried to roll again voter-approved medical marijuana applications.
“This yr particularly, we’re taking part in protection much more than we now have prior to now,” mentioned Morgan Fox, political director on the advocacy group Nationwide Group for the Reform of Marijuana Legal guidelines, or NORML.
To some extent, he mentioned, the pendulum on marijuana liberalization is swinging again. However Fox mentioned latest legislative efforts will not be indicative of waning public assist for legalization. He mentioned prohibitionist politicians have been emboldened to behave towards the desire of voters.
Polling from the Pew Analysis Middle has discovered little change in assist for legalization lately: 57% of U.S. adults say that marijuana must be authorized for medical and leisure functions.
Colorado and Washington state started permitting leisure marijuana gross sales in 2014. At present, 24 states and the District of Columbia permit leisure gross sales, and 39 states and the district have sanctioned medical marijuana.
“There’s been this air of inevitability for some time,” mentioned Daniel Mallinson, an affiliate professor of public coverage at Penn State Harrisburg who researches marijuana legalization.
With medical marijuana applications operational in most states, Mallinson mentioned there may be stress to broaden leisure marijuana, particularly given uncertainty over whether or not the federal authorities will act on the difficulty.
“Leisure remains to be in its takeoff interval,” he mentioned.
However he acknowledged that new medical analysis has raised considerations amongst some lawmakers. One research printed in January discovered a hyperlink between heavy marijuana use and reminiscence perform. Different research have discovered the next danger of coronary heart assaults amongst individuals who use hashish.
Mallinson mentioned the analysis on marijuana is “very younger,” as many establishments are cautious of conducting scientific trials due to federal drug legal guidelines. The federal authorities classifies marijuana as a Schedule I drug— the identical classification as medicine comparable to heroin and ecstasy.
“There’s a mix of science and politics on this space,” he mentioned. “ … I might think about seeing in these actually conservative states like Idaho, you understand, this sort of a backlash, like, we don’t need this right here in any respect, so we’re going to attempt to put up obstacles to even contemplating it.”
A debate headed for the poll
In Idaho, Skaug mentioned he pursued the state’s new obligatory$300 high-quality for marijuana possession to carry extra consistency to how the state handles marijuana instances.
Whereas Idaho legislation beforehand allowed fines of as much as $1,000, he mentioned judges had issued fines as little as $2.50.
“In order that wasn’t the best message. That’s not even well worth the time to put in writing the ticket,” he mentioned. “So it’s not that we’re going to arrest extra individuals for misdemeanor possession of marijuana, however there can be extra citations within the quantity of $300.”
Skaug additionally backed a proposed constitutional modification that will give solely the legislature the facility to legalize marijuana and different medicine. That query will go to voters subsequent yr.
Skaug mentioned he’s nervous outdoors teams would affect a public vote to legalize marijuana by pouring tens of millions right into a poll initiative marketing campaign. If the modification he helps passes, it wouldn’t ban pot — it might go away legalization as much as lawmakers.
“If the proof comes again that claims marijuana or another drug is optimistic within the medical neighborhood and a superb factor, then the legislature can legalize that,” he mentioned. “However we’re going to go away it with the legislature.”
Advocates have been making an attempt with out success to get sufficient signatures to place a medical marijuana query on the poll for greater than a decade in Idaho, mentioned Democratic state Rep. Ilana Rubel. The Home minority chief, Rubel mentioned she hit “a agency brick wall” in pitching medical marijuana laws in Boise, the place GOP lawmakers privately inform her they don’t need to look delicate on crime.
She views the proposed modification as one other instance of the GOP-controlled statehouse being out of contact with common Idahoans. She mentioned the state’s closed Republican primaries have led to extra conservative stances from lawmakers.
“I feel that is a kind of points the place there may be simply an enormous, large hole between what the individuals of Idaho need and what they’re going to get from their legislature,” she mentioned.
A 2022 ballot commissioned by the Idaho Statesman discovered that just about 70% of Idahoans supported legalizing medical marijuana.
However even discussions about medical marijuana are shut down in Idaho due to considerations about issues with medicine in liberal cities comparable to Portland, Oregon, and Seattle, Rubel mentioned.
“A really massive variety of crimson states have legalized medical marijuana, and so they haven’t seen any of the parade of horribles that has been introduced at any time when we introduce this concept,” she mentioned. “There’s simply a number of hysteria and paranoia about the place that is going to steer that’s actually not tied to actuality.”
Focusing on marijuana efficiency, revenues
In a number of states, lawmakers have aimed to limit the efficiency of marijuana merchandise.
Montana state Sen. Greg Hertz, a Republican, mentioned he doesn’t need to finish leisure marijuana gross sales, which voters authorised in 2020. However he mentioned at the moment’s merchandise are a lot stronger than individuals could understand.
“Folks have been voting for Woodstock weed, not this new high-THC marijuana,” he mentioned.
A invoice he sponsored this yr would have banned gross sales of leisure marijuana merchandise, together with flower and edibles, exceeding THC ranges of 15%. Montana presently permits as much as 35% THC in flower, with no restrict on different merchandise.
That laws stalled, however Hertz mentioned he plans to pitch an analogous measure throughout Montana’s subsequent legislative session in 2027.
A separate invoice decreasing the state’s dosage of THC for edibles simply handed the legislature. The measure, which now heads to Republican Gov. Greg Gianforte, would change the person dosage restrict on edibles comparable to gummies from 10 milligrams to five milligrams.
Hertz mentioned the state rushed into its liberalization of marijuana with out totally understanding the implications.
He pointed to state well being division information displaying rising emergency room visits associated to marijuana and dozens of hashish poisoning instances lately — together with 36 involving youngsters 10 years or youthful.
“We most likely opened up the barn door too large,” he mentioned. “I’m simply making an attempt to sluggish this down a bit bit.”
With many states dealing with gaping price range holes this yr, marijuana has confirmed a well-liked goal from Democrats and Republicans trying to increase revenues with out across-the-board tax will increase.
Maryland Democratic Gov. Wes Moore in January proposed mountaineering the hashish tax from 9% to fifteen% to assist shut the state’s $3 billion price range gap. In March, lawmakers agreed to a price range framework that will increase the state marijuana tax to 12%.
Ohio Republican Gov. Mike DeWine proposed doubling marijuana taxes from 10% to twenty% — a notion that has to date confronted opposition within the legislature.
In Michigan, Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer proposed a brand new 32% wholesale tax on marijuana growers to assist fund street enhancements. That tax could be on prime of the ten% excise tax on leisure marijuana and the state’s 6% gross sales tax.
Whitmer mentioned it might shut a loophole that has exempted the marijuana business from wholesale tax, which is utilized to cigarettes and different tobacco merchandise. Michigan lawmakers, break up sharply alongside partisan traces, have till Sept. 30 to approve a state price range.
Lawmakers in some states have even taken intention at voter-approved medical marijuana applications this yr.
In South Dakota, a invoice that failed in committee would have gutted the medical marijuana program overwhelmingly authorised by voters in 2020.
In November, Nebraska voters extensively supported poll measures to roll out a medical marijuana program — profitable majority assist in every of the state’s 49 legislative districts.
However establishing the regulatory scheme has confirmed controversial, the Nebraska Examiner reported. Lawmakers are pursuing laws that will outline which medical situations and types of hashish would qualify.
Medical marijuana advocates say overly strict guidelines would hamper this system and undermine the desire of voters. However some legislators insist on limitations to stop widespread entry to marijuana.
“We make it authorized for something and every thing, it’s primarily leisure marijuana at that time,” state Sen. Rick Holdcroft, a Republican, informed the Nebraska Examiner this month.
Stateline reporter Kevin Hardy might be reached at khardy@stateline.org.
©2025 States Newsroom. Go to at stateline.org. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
Initially Revealed:
