An investor in Fluid Truck, the Denver-based car rental startup, has accused its founders of masterminding a “corrupt, illegal and unconscionable scheme” to take greater than $11 million from car homeowners after which file for chapter to get away with their “bare theft.”
“Merely put, Fluid Truck is stealing from its car homeowners to fund its ongoing operations,” says Tim City, an entrepreneur in Littleton who’s suing on behalf of 100 buyers.
A spokeswoman for Fluid Truck, Emily Allen, declined to debate these theft claims.
“Whereas we can’t touch upon pending litigation, our car homeowners are our high precedence and we proceed to give attention to addressing their wants and driving success for them,” she mentioned.
The corporate was based in Denver in 2016 as Fluid Market, an Uber-for-everything app that allowed customers to lease an enormous assortment of home items and autos. By 2018, it had change into Fluid Truck and centered solely on car leases. It has since expanded to different main cities, raised $63 million in a single funding spherical, and partnered with Ikea.
However City claims that Fluid is now a “failing enterprise” careening in the direction of chapter and a sale to Kingbee Leases, an analogous firm out of Utah. His class motion lawsuit, filed Thursday in Denver’s federal court docket, contains an August electronic mail from Scott Avila, Fluid’s CEO.
“I promised transparency and open communication, so I need to be candid — we face vital monetary challenges that we now have but to resolve for,” wrote Avila, who took over for Fluid’s sibling co-founders James Eberhard and Jenifer Snyder in mid-July.
“Consequently, we’re nonetheless unable to course of arrears funds, together with insurance coverage declare payouts and monies owed for car gross sales,” he defined to City and others. He promised Fluid would do higher sooner or later and has an “unwavering give attention to stabilizing our monetary state of affairs.”
Fluid operates what it calls the Fluid Car Investor Platform, or FVIP, which permits buyers to purchase fleets of autos, lease them out by means of Fluid, and promote them by means of Fluid after they get too outdated. Fluid deducts prices for repairs and costs, then palms the proceeds to buyers.
City says that he invested by shopping for 47 autos, leasing them by means of Fluid, after which letting it public sale off 29 of these. For years, he was glad. Then the calendar turned to 2024.
City says that Fluid has auctioned off 14 autos of his this 12 months for $415,000 and pocketed the entire proceeds. He claims that Fluid has acknowledged owing him $178,000.
“After months of delays, deception and obfuscation concerning the standing of fee, Fluid has lastly admitted to City and different (buyers) that it’s deliberately holding greater than $11 million in stolen funds owed to (them) as gross sales and claims proceeds,” his lawsuit states.
Eberhard and Snyder have been faraway from their government roles to restrict Fluid’s authorized “publicity created by this unlawful scheme” however stay on the board of administrators, in response to City. Snyder, who can be a lawyer, didn’t reply requests for remark. Neither did Eberhard.
“However this supposed change in firm management,” City alleges, “Mr. Avila and the present administration group have continued to perpetuate the identical scheme to steal FVIP homeowners’ cash by holding these funds and refusing to repay the FVIP homeowners.”
City says that he spoke with Doug Trussler, a accomplice at Bison Capital in Los Angeles, this month — Bison was a part of that $63 million capital elevate in 2021 and has a seat on Fluid’s board — and was informed that Fluid “is resolved to maintain the gross sales proceeds stolen from City.”
“To forestall the compensation for Fluid Truck’s widespread theft, Fluid Truck, Bison Capital and different buyers intend to proceed this scheme by gaming the system,” City alleged final week. “Their plan is to put Fluid Truck into chapter 11, make investments a portion of $20 million into Kingbee Leases, after which have Kingbee Leases purchase Fluid Truck’s belongings out of chapter.”
Kingbee, which additionally didn’t return requests for remark, introduced Oct. 3 that it and Fluid could be collaborating to supply their clients with extra car choices. The press launch saying that collaboration didn’t counsel Kingbee could be buying Fluid.
The ouster of Eberhard and Snyder was first reported Aug. 28 by TechCrunch, which wrote that it was executed on the behest of Bison and Ingka Investments, Ikea’s enterprise arm. The transfer adopted steep monetary losses and difficulties paying distributors, TechCrunch reported.
Eberhard, Snyder and Avila are all defendants within the class motion lawsuit towards Fluid, which seeks greater than $11 million and accuses them and their firm of fraud and theft.
City is represented by the attorneys John Crisham and David Holman with Crisham & Holman in Littleton. They and their shopper declined to be interviewed concerning the case Friday.
City’s lawsuit shouldn’t be the one ongoing case towards Fluid. In Colorado Springs, a trucking firm referred to as Field Runner says it has been owed $23,000 from Fluid for six months. Fluid denies owing the cash and says that the dispute ought to be dealt with in arbitration.
Fluid is headquartered at 400 W. forty eighth Ave. in Globeville. Final 12 months, Eberhard sued a developer and actual property dealer for allegedly tricking Fluid into leasing area there by not revealing it was close to a homeless hangout. That case was settled out of court docket six months later.
Get extra enterprise information by signing up for our Financial system Now publication.
Initially Printed:
